Light Minutes of the 14th Symposium
of the Collegium Internationale Allergologicum held in Sorrento, Italy in
October 1982
GEOFFREY B. WEST
1st row (from left): U. Serafini, A de Weck,
A. Sehon; 2nd row (from left): G. Gleich,
K. Ishizaka, T. Ishizaka, M. Metzger, Z. Ovary;
3rd row (from left): P. Dukor, S. Galli,
J. Bousquet, B. Guérin, T. Kishimoto,
H. Spiegelberg. Sorrento, 1982.
For the 14th Meeting of the
CIA, we visited Southern Italy to the seaside resort of Sorrento, just south of
Naples. This was not an easy place to reach and there are many stories of delays
in travel. The best concerns a worker from New Orleans, USA who got as far as
Castel Ammare ( 12 miles from Sorrento ) and then the train he was on went on
strike and for over 2 hours nothing happened. Finally he reached his hotel about
10 p.m., only to find that food was not served after 9:30 p.m.
After a highly successful
"Welcome Cocktail" evening at the Hotel Cocumella (actually in the
cellars where the monks used to concoct their brandy), we got down to work on
Monday October 11th. The Carl Prausnitz Memorial Lecture was presented by Dr.
Metzger on "Taking the receptor for IgE apart and putting it back
again". With some well-chosen slides, the idea of four blind Indians trying
to keep the elephant quiet appealed to the audience, but it was too much when,
for the elephant, the whole zoo was substituted. Nevertheless, most of us
appreciated the value of a detergent-lipid mixture to help separate the B-chain
from the human IgE receptor. But the statement - "Do not worry, my
results are NOT too exciting" - shook most of us.
The rest of the morning was set
aside to IgE receptors and cell activation, with a suitable coffee break
interspersed - the coffee was orange juice and snippets but that didn’t
matter.
Statements on this morning
which attracted my eye were:
- Enzymes increase in cells
but do not increase releases of mediators in the way we would like them to
release;
- In my slides, Normals are
Perfect Patients, chosen perfectly; and
- Mesenteric lymph cells can
be made to produce A) Suppression and B) Potentiation according to needs.
After a so-called "Working
Lunch" taken either in Parco di Principi or Cocumella Hotels, we discussed
the "Regulation of Human IgE synthesis". It was during this session
that we all heard about:
- Public Idiotopes and
Private Idiotopes,
- Circles and Headphones,
- DW2 positive linked to
RA5 negative, and vice versa.
Truly what a performance by
hyphenated immunologists in Naples Bay. At the "General Assembly" that
night, Felix Milgrom ended his term of office as President and Kimmy Ishizaka
took over - and we heard that the next meeting was to be somewhere in the
USA. Meanwhile on this day the ladies (and three men) had been by coach to
Amalfi and Positano for a fine whole-day excursion in pleasant weather.
We awoke on Tuesday to the
sound of thunder and tropical rain. This did not worry most of us but it delayed
the ladies excursion to the Isle of Capri. That morning we heard all about
"Lymphocyte and Mast Cell Populations".
One superb talk came from Dr.
Siraganian from Bethesda, stressing the link between selectivity of arachidonic
acid release by antigen and the involvement of PGs.
After a working lunch again, we
divided for the first of the poster discussions. Most considered it was not a
good idea to divide - chiefly because they were not time-scheduled. During
one of these sessions, we heard that sometimes the unusual does the trick. For
example, a broken-off needle left in the thorax had cured an allergy but the
patient finally had to be controlled - in this case, controlled meant the
patient died.
At 4.30 p.m. we all prepared
for the highlight of the social programme - the visit to the isle of Capri
by Alascarfo. We all noted that the weather was not too settled and the sea was
rough but we did not realise the boat cannot always perform. And so it was. We
all reached halfway to Capri - some sicker than others - and then
the Captain said "Enough is Enough" and we turned round and returned
to Sorrento. What a disappointment! However, the organisers got cracking and a
quickly arranged dinner at a restaurant down town was greatly appreciated.
Incidentally, the ladies of course were with us on this abortive attempt to
reach Capri for the dinner on the island.
Wednesday morning, early again,
saw another divided "poster discussion". I particularly liked one
presenter who kept showing us a picture of himself at work, on the screen as
well as on the Poster board. Statements I heard at the session were:
- The rat mast cell system is
no ordinary system as it is selective for some things;
- The results I show do not
comply with my hypothesis (later this speaker couldn’t think of the word
hypothesis and said Religion, though he didn’t state which - R.C. or
what?); and
- We are now in the age of
FACTORology and soon it will be IgZ.
Wednesday afternoon was Pompei
time and a most exciting two hours we had at the site of this ancient city. That
night, we had the "Social Dinner" and a recital by Peppino Di Capri.
This was music, singing, dancing and local customs - all until 1 a.m.
We ended the meeting on
Thursday morning with a session on mediators of "Allergic Reactions".
Congratulations and thanks go to the organisers - Condorelli, Marone and
Rossi - for a highly successful meeting. I understand that some did get to
Capri later whereas others visited Herculaneum.
|